How to Tell if Your Website is Holding You Back (And What an SEO Consultant Would Say)

Most small business owners have a gut feeling that their website should be doing more. But unless something is obviously broken, it’s hard to tell what’s working and what’s not. You might be getting the odd enquiry, ranking for your brand name, and ticking along – but deep down, you suspect there’s more potential.

Here’s the reality: your website might be holding you back without making it obvious. It could be costing you sales every day, simply by not showing up in the right searches.

So, how do you know besides speaking to an seo consultant?

Below is exactly what an SEO consultant for small business would look at first – no jargon, no padding, just the things that matter.

1. You’re Invisible for Anything Other Than Your Business Name

Search for what you do, not who you are.

If you’re a joiner in Bolton, search “joiner Bolton” or “kitchen fitter Bolton”. If your site only shows up when you search your exact business name, you’re not attracting new leads – just existing ones.

An SEO consultant would check what keywords you’re actually showing up for in Google Search Console. Most small businesses rank for five or six variations of their name – and nothing else. That’s not SEO, that’s a digital business card.

2. You Don’t Have Clear, Specific Pages for Your Services or Areas

Google needs pages with a purpose. If everything you offer is jammed onto one generic services page or your homepage tries to do all the work, search engines will struggle to understand what your business is about.

You need one page per:

• Service (e.g. “Loft Conversions” or “Solar Panel Installation”)

• Location (e.g. “Electrician in Wigan” or “Plasterer in Chorley”)

An SEO consultant would tell you this is where most wins come from. Simple structure, easy wins.

3. The Page Titles Are Wasted

Page titles are one of the biggest missed opportunities. If your homepage title is just “Home” or your About page is called “About Us | Business Name”, Google sees a blank slate.

A consultant would suggest rewriting every title to reflect what people are actually searching for. For example:

Instead of:

“Home | Swift Joinery Solutions”

Use:

“Joiner in Bolton | SwiftJoinery Carpentry & Kitchens”

These things don’t take long to fix, but they make a difference.

4. Your Website Is Slow or Clunky on Mobile

Over 60% of small business web traffic is on mobile. If your site takes 5 seconds to load or the buttons are impossible to press, people leave – and Google notices.

There are free tools like PageSpeed Insights that show you exactly what’s wrong. An SEO consultant will also check how your mobile version renders and if the core layout is causing issues.

This isn’t about scores, it’s about real people using your site.

5. You’re Not Using Internal Links

Google follows internal links to understand what matters on your site. If your blog posts or service pages never mention or link to each other, you’re making Google’s job harder.

This also makes it harder for visitors to find what they’re looking for.

A good SEO consultant would show you how to build internal links that guide both users and search engines through your site – often increasing the time spent on your site and improving rankings in the process.

6. Your Site Looks Good but Says Nothing

Some sites look the part but read like they were written for a brochure in 2009. If your copy is vague, filled with buzzwords, or doesn’t say what you actually do in plain terms, you’ll lose people fast – and Google won’t know what to rank you for.

Ask yourself:

• Does your homepage clearly explain what you offer?

• Can a stranger understand your value in 10 seconds?

• Is your phone number easy to find?

A consultant’s job isn’t to rip your site apart – it’s to strip away the fluff and reveal what matters.

7. You’re Relying on Referrals, Not Organic Leads

This one hits a nerve.

If 90% of your work comes from word of mouth, you’ve likely got a great business – but you’re one algorithm update, economic blip, or personal issue from the work drying up.

SEO shouldn’t replace referrals, but it should give you control. A steady trickle of people finding you through Google – with intent to buy – changes everything.

A good SEO consultant for small business doesn’t just “rank your site.” They help you build a pipeline of leads that doesn’t rely on luck.

In Summary

If your website:

• Doesn’t show up for anything except your name,

• Doesn’t have separate pages for services or areas,

• Has vague titles or confusing copy,

• Is slow, clunky, or neglected,

…then yes, it’s holding you back.

But the good news is this: none of these are hard fixes. You don’t need to rebuild the site or spend thousands. You just need a clear strategy, a few practical changes, and a focus on what real people (and search engines) actually need.

At SEO Organic, we don’t sell monthly packages unless you need one. We’ll just tell you what’s broken and what’s worth fixing. A Professional assessment from someone who’s been on both sides of the table.

Click the button below to book a free website review.

Book A Free Website Review